Our Friends at MojoHost are Free SSL Certificates!'

I really didn't have to do anything, but start typing "https://" rather than "http://" to find that out!

Most subpages or internal pages seem to be following suit as "https://"...

Except for those that I manually created links for as "http://".

Pages that you don't have hardcoded as "http://" are going to upgrade themsevles as "https://"...

The big thing to remember in your Google Webmaster Tools (and Bing):
Search Engines consider "https://mydomain.com" and "http://mydomain.com" as 2 separate websites!

...with separate crawls, separate click histories, sitemaps, indexing, etc.

Ask your web host if SSL Certs are free, have them implement if not already there, get your Webmaster Tools up-to-date to reflect both "https://mydomain.com" and "http://mydomain.com" properties. i.e. add a new property for every "https://mydomain.com".

But, Why are you not already with MojoHost? They've been here on GWW for many years!