Printable View
From other boards and passing them off as your own?
Seems to happen a lot in the gay community.. Especially with people taking thread topics from GWW.
Think this is ethical for a failing board to take active thread ideas from other webmaster communities and post them on their board to get traffic?
Regards,
Lee
..."the question has been answered logan 5"... - logan's run
I answer same topic/questions once , I am noticing that similar topic/questions are being "mirrored" on other sites ( includes blogs ) but that just tells me the publisher is lacking in originality especially when the post contains no mention of it's first publishing and/or original poster.
what attracts me to a board is not so much the questions asked but the answers given , sound information will always triumph over mindless chatter. ( interpreted: be yourself , speak freely but with respect for others , attach a pic for more notice! - just kidding. :) )
jim
I don't think taking an idea from a different board is that bad because, like longboardjim said, it's the responses that often make the thread worth reading. I don't think whole posts should be copied but if a bunch of people on another board have good answers to a question who's to say that a different group of people on this board might not have a wide range of different answers. I've written the same question on different boards before and have even found nothing but positive answers on one board and negative answers on another.
What if it wasnt YOU that started the thread on a board, would you copy it across to a different message board then and ask as if it were your thread?Quote:
Originally Posted by DonMike
Like what some moderators currently do on other boards.
See a thread that has a bunch of replies on a board other than their own, then decide to start the same thread on their board in the hopes to get replies.
Regards,
Lee
If it is not YOUR thread, I do not think you should copy it anywhere else without sourcing it.
I have taken an announcement or important industry-related question posted on one board and posted it on another board (giving credit to where it came from) if I've felt that the information was important enough and needed to be discussed in more than one place.
But if somebody's taking something that someone else posted on one board, reposting it as their own on another board, that isn't OK.
There have been a few times where I'll see a topic I really like on one board that hasn't been brought up on another board where that poster does not visit, and I'll say "I saw this on another board" and then paraphrase the question. I think if it's a situation like that, where it's done by the members occasionally it's okay. I think if its done by the owners of a board on a regular basis just to up the post count it's kind of shady.
If you credit the source it shouldn't be a big deal. I think if it's an industry specific topic that could be a benefit to your board members, cut/paste/credit is okay.
I agree.Quote:
Originally Posted by maxx68
and I don't think giving credit is saying "I found this on another board"
Giving credit would be " I found this posted on GWW by Lee " etc. and linking to the thread. Anything else is tacky and cheap IMO :snake:
See im happy to just have 'saw this on GWW' but even that doesnt happen LOLQuote:
Originally Posted by Squirt
Regards,
Lee
I think that's a bit much. I mean, we're talking posts on a message board here not a work of literature. If I had a good thread and saw someone else had posted the idea on another board I would simply read what others had to say on the topic. If they copied and pasted my exact words I'd be a little annoyed but not if it's just the idea.Quote:
Originally Posted by Squirt
Strictly speaking, we're talking copyrighted works, i dont know about other boards but whenever anyone signs up to GWW they assign the rights of any posts they make over to us... Therefore, for all intents and purposes, when this happens and someone takes a post from GWW and posts it elsewhere, they are commiting copyright infringement $0.02Quote:
Originally Posted by DonMike
Regards,
Lee
Well, I did say reposting of ideas and not copying actual text. And an occasional crossover is quite different than another board taking all of your posts to their boards. I don't think that is right either. I'm only talking in a general sense, as in "hey, i saw this on another board" type of posts.Quote:
Originally Posted by Lee
Yeah I get what you're saying.Quote:
Originally Posted by DonMike
If I do 20 minutes of research to find something interesting and new not posted on boards to contribute something unique, and Joe Shmoe just copies what I found and posts it on a board that I'm band from it would piss me off a bit but on the flip side when I see it done I laugh at how unoriginal some people can be LOL
At the end of the day it's not a drama for me, or I would have mentioned it at some point over the years.
Yeah, I guess there are two sides to the coin. I was ready to keep going with my side but then I stopped and thought, "wait, let's look at what he's really saying" and you know, we both have good points. :)Quote:
Originally Posted by Squirt
Thats typically my reaction also to be honest.Quote:
Originally Posted by Squirt
Regards,
Lee
You do actually, i only started this thread from the 'protect my business' angle but i can definitely see how in some instances cross-posting thread ideas could be a great help to the larger community.Quote:
Originally Posted by DonMike
I guess it comes down to WHY the thread was copied, to gain traffic or to spread information.
If its a topic that has a lot of replies that is copied, without or with relatively little 'business' information i tend to look at that as 'trying to build traffic' as oppose to 'sharing information' myself, especially when it is a vague topic that hardly anyone else would have thought about posting, such as that Craigslist missed connections thread as an example.
Regards,
Lee
We do because we're both two unique amazingly fabulous people :bunny: :bunny:Quote:
Originally Posted by DonMike
though you have the gift of sounding cooler in text then I do :balls:
Hitting the nail right on the head. :)Quote:
Originally Posted by Lee
Quote:
Originally Posted by Squirt
It's just the writer in me. :)
So you're getting fucked when posting? What's the writers name?Quote:
Originally Posted by DonMike