American Idol result :(

CamCruise · 05-17-2007, 08:17 PM

Originally Posted by MiamiB

I would like to state that I have NEVER seen the show and I have NEVER had the desire to.

Guess that makes me strange right?

Lee

I knew I liked you LEE. Thanks God there is at least two of us that do not care about this stuff!!

**SPACE GLIDER** · 05-18-2007, 12:38 AM

Blake didn't sing nearly as well. He really was voted for his face.

I still wonder how that ugly Kelly Clarkson won. She had no talent AND she was unattractive compared to several of her competitors.

**scorpio** · 05-18-2007, 12:42 AM

Originally Posted by SPACE GLIDER

Blake didn't sing nearly as well. He really was voted for his face.

I still wonder how that ugly Kelly Clarkson won. She had no talent AND she was unattractive compared to several of her competitors.

The only thing i agree with you is about Blake not singing well. As far as his face goes, eewww! And about Kelly Clarkson, i actually think the girl can sing her heart out, and i also find her attractive.

It's all about retarted people voting. AI/presidential... same thing. Not a big surprise anymore.

**Mansized** · 05-18-2007, 02:17 AM

Originally Posted by haganxy

you are correct. that is how America votes. pretty faces sell albumns, and the companies are out there to make money. how well someone sings is not as important as someone who is "cute". many times you will hear the judges say how certain contestants have the "look".

such is life...

Then explain Reuben to me!

**Mansized** · 05-18-2007, 02:19 AM

Originally Posted by scorpio

The only thing i agree with you is about Blake not singing well. As far as his face goes, eewww! And about Kelly Clarkson, i actually think the girl can sing her heart out, and i also find her attractive.

It's all about retarted people voting. AI/presidential... same thing. Not a big surprise anymore.

Scorpie!! Good to "See" ya!!

**Ethan Masters** · 05-18-2007, 09:57 AM

However, the show is called "American Idol", not "American best vocalist"

People vote on the person that they can best idolize with, not just someone with a pretty voice that is going to end up on the radio anyways someday. Melinda has an amazing voice, and is definitely the best singer, but I don't think she has the best capacity for "idol" material. The whole innocent turtle thing going on...

**scorpio** · 05-18-2007, 10:57 AM

Originally Posted by Mansized

Scorpie!! Good to "See" ya!!

Thank you

**XXXWriterDude** · 05-18-2007, 02:29 PM

Originally Posted by Sha

Nah not strange at all Lee. Probably just a better person for not seeing it. Each year they somehow get millions of fans (including myself) to watch it and then get pissed because America votes on popularity or sex appeal instead of talent. I keep saying that I will stop watching it but I am sure I will be back next year.

I was so turned off by the very first season (and that HORRIBLE "Up with People," stupid '50s and '60s music shit that sounded like I was watching a junior high school recital) that I've never become a fan. I follow what goes on and who all the contestants are, because as an entertainment journalist, it's my job to know who these folks are, but I don't watch. I've watched 3 episodes in my life, and all three times they voted off the people I thought should have won, so I just got so pissed that I didn't continue. That's the problem with America. Americans rarely appreciate true talent. They vote for pretty faces and riff-raff who sing formulaic crap that we've heard a thousand times before.

**EonFilms_Rocky** · 05-18-2007, 02:42 PM

Originally Posted by Ethan Masters

Melinda has an amazing voice, and is definitely the best singer, but I don't think she has the best capacity for "idol" material. The whole innocent turtle thing going on...

I think she looks like Shrek.