Why are gay people against brokeback mountain?

[Jasun]

Why make another action hero movie?

well, after Hulk, I don't think they should.... :jasun: ( I still say Hulk is the worst movie ever made... I also still hope someone punched him in the face for ruining one of the coolest comic books ever)

that being said, you're right.. it's all been done before.

[mardigras]

My biggest negative with Brokeback Mountain was that it is about 30 minutes too long. There are too many extraneous scenes that do nothing to continue the story or develop the characters and the editing leaves them disjointed and as if they had cut chunks out of a much longer film trying to get it to a comfortable length. I was brokeback after sitting in the theater that long:high:

[DonMike]

My biggest negative with Brokeback Mountain was that it is about 30 minutes too long. There are too many extraneous scenes that do nothing to continue the story or develop the characters and the editing leaves them disjointed and as if they had cut chunks out of a much longer film trying to get it to a comfortable length. I was brokeback after sitting in the theater that long:high:

You know, I've often thought that it was a shame big Hollywood movies only show you what you need to see. I loved Dazed and Confused because the whole movie was a day in the life of these high school kids in 1976. There were small plot lines and one thread that kept the movie running, but not every scene had significant importance, a lot of it just made you feel good or unlock a memory. There have been lots of movies where I wished they had shown more of a really cool supporting character but wouldn't because it didn't further the plot. I haven't seen Brokeback yet so I'm not disagreeing with you. Your comment just made me think of that.

[XXXWriterDude]

My biggest negative with Brokeback Mountain was that it is about 30 minutes too long. There are too many extraneous scenes that do nothing to continue the story or develop the characters and the editing leaves them disjointed and as if they had cut chunks out of a much longer film trying to get it to a comfortable length. I was brokeback after sitting in the theater that long:high:

Actually, Brokeback is really only 2 hours long, the same length as many other movies. I think it's because the pacing is so languid that it made it feel long for you. I've seen it four times now, and it doesn't seem nearly as long the second time.

And I'm with DonMike. I LOVE long movies. Anytime there is a 3-hour movie coming out, I RUSH to the theater. Some of my favorite movies ever are the longer ones. The three Lord of the Rings movies didn't even become MOVIES for me until they released the extended cuts on DVD. I don't have a short attention span. Hell, when they played Branagh's 4-hour Hamlet, I was in heaven. Now THAT's a cinematic experience!

[rhys]

man... just saw the movie

what a disappointment(aside form jake whatshisname.. he rocks!)

reminded me of titanic... way too much hype for an overblown story.

in this case it was a elegaic short story turned into a bloated hollywood flick... sigh.

things got pretty bad when i kept hoping for more shorts of gorgeous alberta scenery!

like i said in the first of these brokeback threads.... read the story
i should have take my own advice and stayed away from this stinker of movie

[Gay Porn Corner]

Well I can actually say I haven't seen Brokeback Mountain, but I will probably get it when it comes out on DVD. I have said this before when this subject has come up. I don't know if anyone here has seen "Latter Days" since there has been no mention of it. It is a powerful movie that honestly will make you think. I purchased the DVD on a whim and totally lost it the first time I saw it and then last night on LOGO they played it and it's as powerful the second time around as it was the first. I watched it and thought to myself. Everyone is making all the noise about Brokeback Mountain and how could they let Latter Days go by un-noticed. Could it be because it’s based on the Mormon Religion belief that all gays are going to hell. If you want to really do some soul searching check it out. I truly don't think you would be disappointed, matter of fact you just may learn a thing or two. Well that’s just my thought anyway, but I am curious if anyone else has seen it and what they thought?

Marc

[DonMike]

I don't know if anyone here has seen "Latter Days" since there has been no mention of it.

Actually, I did see Latter Days. The director, CJ Cox, was dating a friend of mine and when my friend introduced me he kept saying that the guy was the director of "Sweet Homo Alabama". Well, I figured he was just in the industry. So I'm talking to him like he's a fellow pornographer and I'm saying that I work in the industry too, I do music and sales and blah blah blah. So finally he says something about Reese Witherspoon, and I got all confused. Then it hit me. My friend was making a joke about his having directed "Sweet Home Alabama". I was mortified. I said, "you work in real movies, I thought you worked in porn" and they all had a good laugh. So when Latter Days came out we all ran to see it just because we had hung out with CJ.

I was not raised Mormon, but a lot of my friends were, and I was raised in a small town, with small town values and I could see my mom being just like the mother of the young Mormon guy who's fallen in love with the Hollywood stud. Mary Kay Place played an excellent role and I was sobbing loudly when he confronts her about his sexuality. It hit me too close to home and I really needed to take a little time to reflect on it all.

If you have not seen Latter Days I highly recommend it.

[Lee]

If you have not seen Latter Days I highly recommend it.

I do too.. Those mormon guys in the movie are hawt

Regards,

Lee

[jIgG]

my boyfriend saw Latter Days
he wants to make me see it because it's so great but so far I'm holding up :vanish:

[Lee]

my boyfriend saw Latter Days
he wants to make me see it because it's so great but so far I'm holding up :vanish:

He just wants you to see it so he can talk you in to wearing one of those mormon costumes

But yeah, it really is a good movie, id watch it again

Regards,

Lee

[dexxxter]

I saw it soon after it hit the theater's here. I thought is was a pretty good movie. It was well acted, written and followed a story line. Now, there wasn't the kind of nudity or sex that we see in mainstream straight movies but does every movie have to have that? It was set in a time period that I thought accurately portrayed. It was sad, but true to life. It was also a huge step for gay characters that aren't the typical sterotypes: best friend, funny, tragic, psycotic that dies by a crime, show tunes queen. I would say go see it first then judge it. I have seen Will & Grace a few time and do not care for it. But at least I watched it to form an opinion.

[hdkbill]

i guess for me, that's the problem. i don't want my heart ripped out. there are other kinds of impact a movie can have besides tragedy - but unfortunately tragedy is the easiest to acheive.

Saw it the other day. Very well put together, in fact, a great movie. Didn't "rip my heart out" but it did have a sad ending. It's a film everyone should see.

Bill

[XXXWriterDude]

man... just saw the movie

what a disappointment(aside form jake whatshisname.. he rocks!)

reminded me of titanic... way too much hype for an overblown story.

in this case it was a elegaic short story turned into a bloated hollywood flick... sigh.

Well, if you let the "hype" affect how you view the movie, of course you'll be disappointed. If you take it on its own merits, I think it's a rather beautiful movie, regardless of what the press (or any of us here) are saying about it. Always best to judge a movie on its own merits, and not let things like "hype" define your reaction.

[XXXWriterDude]

Incidentally, it looks like Brokeback is indeed opening doors for other gay and lesbian films to get made. As some of you may know, I also read scripts for production companies and studios here in town as a "reader" (or "story analyst," as we are also called), and I was just given a script to read that is gay-themed. I can't say much about it, apart from the fact that it, too, is based on a novel (by a pretty well-known author who's had another book turned into an Oscar-nominated movie with homoerotic undertones) and is also set in the 1950s, but the similarities end there. This one ends, notably enough, on a positive note for its characters. It's actually a very good script, and could also attract A-list talent, though it remains to be seen whether or not it will get the greenlight. Still, the good news is that the studios and production companies are at least considering such stories. At least I think so...

[XXXWriterDude]

Just came across this GREAT story by a friend of mine. He wrote it for Out.com. For anyone who doesn't think that Brokeback Mountain is a profoundly resonant film that tells it like it is and is very important to the gay community, you should read this. You may dislike the movie yourself for "political" reasons, but stories like this prove, to me at least, that gay politics are irrelevant when telling a story that has such far-reaching potential as Brokeback.

http://www.out.com/detail.asp?id=16810&t=senior_moment