Aw shit, this could take a minute...But here are some of my favorites, even with xtra short reviews and a 5 star rating-system :p

Some favorites:

Totally Fucked Up (gay city kids deal with life) ****
Doom Generation (boy-boy-girl love triangle tragedy) ***
Nowhere (teens of the future deal with life) ***
The Living End (too strange for review) ****
Soldier's Girl (transexual club performer falls for doomed soldier) *****
Get Real (british schoolboy crushes on a hot jock) *****
Circuit (flakey pretty boys dance, drug, and fuck) ****
Total Eclipse (period drama, old gay poet falls for young gay poet) ***
Johns (gay hustlers dream of escaping to the country) ****
Party Monster (gay club queens self destruct) *****
My Own Private Idaho (gay hustlers behave very strangely) ***
Urbania (just watch it, you won't regret it!) *****
Poison (gay prison love) ****
Happy Together (Hong Kong lovers travel, cheat, break up) *****

There are so many other great ones, and that isn't even getting into the huge selection of wonderful lesbian titles!