Hey everyone, long time lurker, first time poster. I have a question for you wise people. I currently operate an increasingly popular gay community site. Our primary focus is allowing users to create profiles, one on one video chat, group chat, forums, browse affiliate content, etc. I was starting to think that it might be a good opportunity to create a members area to post exclusive content but the more I thought about it it might not be a good idea. Instead I was thinking about just setting up a new site and try to entire people over there. Thought would be that if I added a whole new members area to the existing site, I risk diluting the site and making navigation a nightmare. What do you think? Can premium content and a social network coexist?

Any help would be appreciated.

Thanks!