No surprise here, but the big question left is will the DoJ recognize this ruling?

Everyone assumed they did just that after Sundance, and then suddenly the updated 2257 popped up with the DoJ claiming that the Library Assn. ruling cancels out the Sundance ruling.

I will not feel completely safe regardless of any ruling until the DoJ is forced to actually change the text of 2257. They are constantly going to cite the Library Association case ruling that supports secondary requirements.

On the plus side, the secondary producer rulings are now two on one.