decent based on whose opinion (web master or surfer) and what variable/s (conversions/sales/performance, design, content, personal preference etcetera)?

As a webmaster, yes, I strongly believe a decent site (based purely on performance, because nothing else matters) can be created by a person who isn't, or persons whom aren't, 'in to' it or aligned with whatever ideology the site promotes.

I, more or less, agree with what abostonboy stated (excluding the despise portion): ...there is no emotional attachment to it. It's strictly business and the bottom line. They are willing to go out and spend the $$$ to do it right.

From a surfers point of view: I couldn't care much less about whatever 'personal touches' the operator adds.
At the end of the day, it is all about content and how much you can cram down my throat. Give me a few morsels and you've just given me the time to find another love.
Throw as much content as you can at me, this way I will not be able to find time to go shopping.