Well I have a bit different view...

What matters most to a me as a gay webmaster :

1. That AEN is not putting pictures of any kind of women on any tours or on any pages whatsoever.... That's the first thing that comes to my mind... It's very very very disturbing

2. $ per recurring sales

3. Quality and quantity of the content they alone can offer to members (videos, magazines, clips, cams....)

4. time they need to include sites I've listed

5. Do they offer upsell (platinum, gold...)

6. That They don't list crappy sites as it makes the whole AEN company look bad

7. Option to rearrange TOUR to my site needs

8. Good layout (for instance: really disturbing layout would be RainbowPassport)

9. That their members passwords are not being exposed too much AROUND the different groups, and websites... (hackers)