Okay, I'll jump in here.

The first thing that struck me was the name of the site. I just don't know any gay men who use the word "gents." But that's okay, it's a neat name, I like the alliteration and it's easy to remember. However, the models on the site thus far do not fit what I would consider "gents" or "gentlemen."

Although I might call a leather man, "sir," he's no gentlemen. Guys in uniforms, too, I wouldn't classify them as "gents." You've got a couple of guys in suits and they're fine. Take a look at http:www.menatplay.net, now those guys I consider more gentlemanly, but "gents" seems to suggest a mature age, too, so I'd tend to classify the menatplay guys as business men, executives, power suits, even GUPPIES (gay urban professionals, although it's an outdated word).

And what do you mean by "for the gay man with more seasoned tastes?" It seems to me like you're trying to say "mature." If so, the models don't suit that. Will West is certainly mature, but if you've watch any of his movies, he ain't no gentleman, and I mean that in a complimentary way.

I like your logo a lot and I like the overal layout of the design of the pages. The pictures have been cropped and place in a good way to meet Badpuppy's "no dick" rule.

I think with a bit of tweaking on the outside, you've got a winner!

Cheers
Dzinerbear