Again my standard disclaimer:

I am SOOOOO not an expert!

OK, my one thought is it seems the content and the sponsor links are too distinct. I might add more links along the lines of "Click here to see Guy shoot his load" Or "Click to watch Guy's real amateur video."

I did notice the ATK Galleria has great design: simple, clear and professional, and excellent images. I wonder if tweaking the design and using at least some non-video caps would help.

I also didn't see a 2257 notice on your site and was wondering about that.