I've considered this a beautiful site for a long while - from a design standpoint and from a SEO standpoint. But looking at it as I think a surfer might ... here's some suggestions

1. Get more aggressive on the "enter such and such gallery" link on the individual guys pages ... Literally tell them to JOIN NOW or CLICK HERE for instant access to the full gallery. Maybe make the join link animate to draw their eye since your pages don't use a lot of animation, it should be effective.

2. Get that join page to where that's all there is ... the join form. A guy with a hardon isn't reading that there is 4 million eight hundred and ninety pics. He just wants to get to the section of the guy that just got him all worked up.

3. Initially when you hit the site, it gives the impression it's a free gallery site ... and there is plenty there that could indeed get a guy off without whipping out the wallet. Maybe cut back a bit on the full pages, do maybe 8-10 full pages, with just head shots/names in a strip of other models inside?

4. I didn't find ANY words or links reminding me to bookmark that site. And in all honesty, that domain name would be a tough one for someone to mentally remember and just type it in again at a later date.

5. Something to try just to see what happens - get a domain name that fits the uncut niche - mirror that same exact site on it, perhaps using dif guys for the full pagers, and change any mentions of the domain name that might be there of course ... and see what that does for traffic and conversions.

6. I also agree you have too many traffic leaks. You have the trader recips on the first page, but then you also have a links page. This only serves to give your surfer other venues to seek out more free stuff. Personally, I'd find sites that will take a link without demanding a recip, or ones that let you list them INSIDE the member area, and use your hubs to get traffic over and then the tour seals the deal.

A tour needs to take the surfer to the join, and nowhere else. Recall the discussion about more free porn hubsites we had awhile back - and mentioned the mancheck more free porn link - it's like what -a 6 pixel font link at the very bottom of the page - so anyone actually clicking it means they went thru the tour and didn't want what they had for sale and went elsewhere... but they had to hunt for it to see that there too. Just something to think about.