Andy,

Your site's still number one for "gay redheads." The problem is that you're not consistent in your choice of keywords. You're using: gay redhead, gay redheads, red head, redhead, redhead men.

"Gay Redhead" is only actually used twice on the page I looked at. You have no ALT tags that I could see. You have no links on the page for "gay redheads." You have too many keywords in your meta tag. You only have five sites linking to this site and that's not a great number. And if you were going after "gay redhead" then that needs to be the keyword phrase used in your title. Remember, SEO experts usually suggest you go after only a couple of keywords per page.

I think your drop in rankings has more to do with sloppy SEO than a major change in the algorithm. I think if you cleaned some of the above up, you'd see that you'd bounce back. If you want me to look at a couple of your other phrases, you know where to find me.

dzinerbear